What do “cabin” and “cottage mean to you? To me a cabin has to be small and simple, fairly rustic inside and out, preferably knotty pine on the inside with pine floors and a stone fireplace (maybe the only source of heat). The bedrooms (no more than 2 of them) usually didn’t have any closets and maybe there was a sleeping loft. The kitchen was basic and not a separate room—a stove, refrigerator and sink with little storage because you didn’t need it. The furnishings were hand-me-downs from home—”comfortable”. There was one bathroom. That’s a rule, hard and fast. If it has more than one bathroom it cannot be a cabin. You went to your cabin to do as little as possible, so there was no landscaping, just woods, and the hardest work was cutting firewood.
In my mind, a “cottage” can be a bit more—they were the “cabins” of the more well-to-do. They could be larger, but still exuded a “lodge” atmosphere (think Adirondack aand wicker furniture and Pendelton blankets). Some of the Door County cottages still exist in areas like Cottage Row in Fish Creek, Point Beach in Egg Harbor, Beach Road in Sister Bay, Chapel Lane in Baileys Harbor, and North Shore Road in Ephraim. Cottages were a place to vacation with your family and friends, but in a more elegant manner.
Cabins, on the other hand, tended to either be tucked away in the woods or on small lakes like Kangaroo Lake in Baileys Harbor and Clark Lake in Jacksonport. Since they were so insubstantial to begin with, now they are usually considered tear-downs. Some have survived, ironically, by being turned into condominiums. There are several examples of that on Kangaroo Lake where the little cabins that were small resorts have been sold as separate condominium units. Happily, they retain their cabin character. Cabins are great precisely because they are small and force their inhabitants to interact in close quarters talking, playing games, and just having fun together!
So, if you end up calling us to buy a cottage, cabin, condominium, land or any other Door County real estate, think about what you really want to do in Door County. Will it be a simple get-away, an investment, your year-around home or your home for retirement? Just maybe an old-fashioned cabin would be right for you!
A POST SCRIPT: Yesterday I was showing homes to a lady and lo and behold, we found an actual cabin that fit my definition of “cabin”! It is a cute little place actually on the shore with two bedrooms (no closets—on of my requirements) and only one bathroom. It’s down south of Sturgeon Bay on the shore, so is much, much more affordable than shore properties, even vacant one, in the northern part of the county, and it was really fun to see it.